Amateur — Stories with amateurs

More foreplay, birth control, bareback, raw, creampie, condom, kiss, insertion, leg wrap, dishonesty, safe sex, condom off, condom removed, no condom, stealthing, unsafe, unwanted, bare, cum in condom, condom broke, condom break, unprotected, seduction, flirting, oral sex, eat out, cunnilingus, contraception, surprise creampie, cum inside, unwanted creampie, unsafe sex, impreg, breeding, bred, sex, stealth creampie, pull out, riding, no birth control, no pill, unprotected sex, cum, precum, fdom, risky, plan b, late pull out, risk, male perspective, female perspective, party, college, gym, lace, alt, egirl, muscle, frat, slut, bathroom, liquor, dirty talk, blowjob, oral creampie, oral, head, dating, facial, handjob, swallow, pregnancy talk, came inside, broken condom, condom removal, cremapie, virgin, cum in mouth, fingering, wet, begging

More secrets, friendship, friends, pointless music references, tension, teen, coin toss, truth, dread, lying, fight, triangle, music, sad, self pity, female POV, unprotected, risky, pregnancy risk, raw, deflowering, virgin, revelations, broken hearts, drama, questioning, interrogation, angst, teens, breakup, makeup, bisexual, MMF, MF, threesome, fuckfest, free love, friends with benefits, first time, moody, broody, foreplay, making out, kissing, boner, talk later, secret, suggestive, upbeat, silly, reflection, inspirational, romance, love, safe dick, shower wank, overhearing, male masturbation, accidental voyeurism, embarrassment, awkward, caretaking, creampie, queer romance, broken hearts, reconciliation, MM, FM, truth or dare, flirting, confrontation, sexual frustration, disappointing, fantasizing, dreams, love declaration, relationship, kiss, makeout, friend, mistake, it's complicated, first kiss, skinny dipping, sex discussion, queer, virginity, relationships, after kissing, reader poll, former queer romance, revelation